Go to the Make.org website

citizens’ consultationResults - What are your ideas for shaping AI to serve the public good?

Consultation initiated by:
  • SciencesPo,
  • AI & Society Institute,
  • The Future Society,
  • Conseil National du Numérique (CNUM),
  • Make.org
  • Consultation ending date : 4 Nov 2024
  • Proposals : 649
  • Participants : 11,661

Total number of votes

: 121,325 out of 100,000 votes (121%)

What can we take away from the consultation?

The top popular ideas, grouped into 6 themes

The best citizens’ proposals are grouped into big ideas that structure the consultation. To classify these ideas, the Make.org algorithm takes into account the votes 'I agree' and 'I disagree' as well as any use of the terms 'Favourite', ‘Realistic’, 'Obvious' and 'Nonsense!'.

  • Monitor the expansion of AI and better define its role in society.

    86% I agreeFavourite 21% Realistic 28%

  • Harmonise ethics and global governance of AI.

    85% I agreeFavourite 19% Realistic 25%

  • Leverage AI to safeguard democracies.

    84% I agreeFavourite 20% Realistic 27%

  • Strengthen legal frameworks to better regulate AI usage.

    81% I agreeFavourite 19% Realistic 22%

Mapping of the debate

Use the control buttons, the "left" and "right" arrows and the tab key on your keyboard to interact with the carousel below.
  • Item 1 of 1

    Cited Themes

    Cited Themes
    NameValue in percentage
    Role of AI in society15%
    Governance14%
    Organization and processes12%
    AI education and training11%
    AI Regulation10%
    Crisis prevention and management7%
    AI innovation6%
    Environmental impact5%
    Autres16%

Most controversial proposals

“Controversial” ideas reflect a significant division in society: they are both strongly supported and strongly rejected.

  • Proposal from: Maryline
    Proposal content

    We need to stop using AI, as we can already see the perverse uses to which it is put.

    49% 'I agree'39% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Olivier
    Proposal content

    We need to use AI to simplify all administrative procedures and rules.

    43% 'I agree'43% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Jean
    Proposal content

    We need to use AI as a cost killer in certain administrations to limit costs and increase efficiency.

    40% 'I agree'44% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Gégé
    Proposal content

    AI should be banned outright. It's an absolute nuisance and a technology that destroys jobs and creates misery.

    44% 'I agree'38% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Delete_requested
    Proposal content

    From secondary school onwards, teachers need to take AI training courses to integrate it into their lessons.

    40% 'I agree'42% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Jean
    Proposal content

    We need to offer AI tools to help students revise, such as creating new exercises for practice.

    40% 'I agree'40% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Jeannine
    Proposal content

    AI needs to play a major role in judicial investigations to ensure faster resolutions, even for old cases.

    50% 'I agree'36% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Philippe
    Proposal content

    Public institutions must create AI to serve major social and environmental causes (food waste).

    47% 'I agree'36% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Marthe
    Proposal content

    We need to develop ethical AI for predictive analysis of public policies and their long-term impact.

    50% 'I agree'33% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Axa
    Proposal content

    Nous devrions préparer les gens aux emplois d'aujourd'hui et de demain en les formant à l'utilisation de l'IA et en leur faisant comprendre comment elle peut améliorer leurs performances.

    45% 'I agree'38% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: David
    Proposal content

    Everyone needs to learn how to use AI, which implies time for training, and the means to access it.

    48% 'I agree'33% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Philippe
    Proposal content

    AI needs to automate the categorization and tracking of citizen requests to improve administrative responsiveness.

    50% 'I agree'35% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Claire
    Proposal content

    We need to build confidence in AI and make it an ethical tool at everyone's service

    32% 'I agree'53% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Jessica
    Proposal content

    We need to create a platform for AI-enhanced democracy, enabling every citizen to engage, vote, contribute, understand...

    32% 'I agree'51% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Rose
    Proposal content

    AI must be used to help judges better manage and apply sentences for repeat offenders

    33% 'I agree'55% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Alexis
    Proposal content

    Il faut soutenir les reconversions pour préparer les travailleurs à l'ère de l'IA.

    53% 'I agree'29% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Paul
    Proposal content

    We need to introduce AI management and decision-making tools for hospital administration as soon as possible to save money.

    28% 'I agree'59% 'I disagree'

  • Proposal from: Théo
    Proposal content

    AIs must help change the lives of the homeless

    41% 'I agree'26% 'I disagree'

Consultation’s participants

Use the control buttons, the "left" and "right" arrows and the tab key on your keyboard to interact with the carousel below.
  • Item 1 of 2

    Participation by Age

    Participation by Age
    Votes (Value in percentage)Population (Value in percentage)
    16- 2411%13%
    25-3410%14%
    35-448%15%
    45-5416%16%
    55-6424%16%
    65+29%26%
  • Item 2 of 2

    Votes by Gender

    Votes by Gender
    NameValue in percentage
    Men50%
    Women46%
    Non binary4%

Context

Consultation citoyenne réalisée par Make.org du 2024-09-18 au 2024-11-04, autour de la question: What are your ideas for shaping AI to serve the public good?

Learn moreOpen in a new window

Download the full report

To obtain the full analysis report for this consultation, click on the button below.

Download the full report